Jurassic Park and Tremors – two film franchises that have far more in common than one might think.

Yes the differences between the two franchises are huge; budgets, popularity, settings etc.  But when it comes down to it both movie series (having 7 flicks each thus far) are at their core about humans genetically messing with creatures from the dawn of time, before those same creatures then turn around and systematically hunt and kill the humans for their hubris.

Movie Review – Tremors 6: A Cold Day in Hell

Both franchises have their big monsters – the T-Rex and the Graboid respectively.  And they both have their flying monsters – the Pteradon and the Assblaster.  But what about those mid-sized creatures that love to run down humans for lunch?  In Jurassic Park these are the Velociraptors and in Tremors they are the Shriekers.

Note both the Raptors and the Shriekers are fictional.  Yes Raptors did actually exist, but they were around the size of large chickens and had feathers as well as scales; they were not 2-meter tall pack hunters that could use doorhandles and change their gender as needed.  And Shriekers are completely fictional, the mid-life cycle of Graboids before they turn into Assblasters, which then in turn lay eggs that turn into baby Graboids.

In both film franchises the species in question get genetically modified by humans, as well as attempts being made by humans to train their packs.  In the first Jurassic Park film, we find that Raptors have only been able to be resurrected by splicing their DNA with that of amphibians, which not only leads to them coming back to life but also being able to change their gender in order to breed.  By the end of the Tremors movies, humans have been messing with the DNA of Shriekers, giving them a ‘Sonic Scream’ that can completely incapacitate their prey.

In the Tremors TV series, it is revealed that the government has secretly been trying to train Shriekers to use their infrared vision in order to find victims in disaster areas.  In Jurassic Park, the Raptors have been trained for several different reasons, from being killing machines for the Military to simply ‘lets see if we can’.

 

So what if these two fictional pack-hunting creatures went head-to-head?  The Jurassic vs The Pre-Cambrian –  Who would win?

To answer this, we will break down the skills and abilities of both Raptors and Shriekers.  Then examine the threat posed by the two species to humans, as well as to each other.

 

Shriekers vs Raptors – The Stats:

Size & Strength

Shriekers: Shriekers are approximately 1 meter high and 1.5 meters long.  They are strong enough to pin down a human and their bite is strong enough to rend metal.

Raptors: Approximately 2 meters high and 2.5 meters long.  They are much stronger than humans in all regards.

Winner: Raptors

 

Speed & Agility:

Shriekers: For such short stubby creatures, Shriekers can exhibit quite a turn of speed, being able to easily keep pace with a human running.  They are also able to jump and pivot easily.

Raptors: Raptors are very fast creatures, able to chase down humans that are riding quad bikes and motorcycles.  They have great leaping skills.

Winner: Raptors

 

Dexterity:

Shriekers: Shrikers have no front appendages, severely limiting their dexterity.  They however have prehensile tongues, being able to to grab objects in much the way an elephant would use their trunks.

Raptors: Raptors have been observed being able to use their hands/claws to not only grab onto their enemies, but even successfully manipulate door handles and other objects.

Winner: Raptors

 

Intelligence:

Shriekers: Whilst Shriekers have been mistaken for having high intelligence (destroying cars and communication towers, seemingly cutting off their prey from outside assistance) they are actually considered relatively dense.  That said, the army has been able to have some success with training Shriekers, and they have been observed being able to figure out puzzles such as how to reach high objects, which puts them above much of the animal kingdom.

Raptors: Raptors have been shown to have high intelligence (for animals), being able to utilize techniques such as distraction, misdirection, testing & assessing and even tool manipulation.

Winner: Raptors

 

Hunting/Pack Hunting:

Shriekers: Shriekers are able to utilize heat sensors on the tops of their heads in order to locate their prey.  This is highly effective, though can cause them to attack inanimate objects that also radiate heat.  Shriekers will emit loud shrieks (hence the name) to alert other Shriekers to potential prey – whilst they have no ears, the shrieking makes them give off more heat themselves as a signal to the rest of the pack. Shriekers can not only hunt and corral their prey by moving in packs, but can also work together to reach prey, such as standing on each others shoulders to reach victims that are high up. Shriekers that have been genetically modified can also subdue prey with a Sonic Scream attack that incapacitates their prey.

Raptors: Raptors are able to use their speed and size to quickly take down most any prey that are smaller than them.  Raptors are excellent pack hunters, able to corral their prey by approaching from multiple directions at once, or using one member to distract their prey whilst the rest of the pack sneak up on their quarry from other sides.  Raptors understand using cover and will use long grasses and bushes to disguise their approach.

Winner: A draw

 

Physical Offensive & Defensive Capabilities:

Shriekers: Shriekers have strong bone jaws that are able to slice through tough materials such as metal with ease, as well as feeling no ill effects from biting through objects that are hot or conducting electricity.  They are able to use their tongues to grab an object/prey.  Genetically modified Shriekers can unleash a Sonic Scream, causing major damage and incapacitation to their prey.  All Shriekers have a hard bone carapace over their heads, making their heads all but impervious to attack

Raptors: Raptors have long thick spurs on their hind legs which are able to rip through flesh with ease.  Raptors have claws on both front appendages, able to grab and tear at their enemies.  Raptors have a mouth full of razor-sharp teeth, able to rend the flesh from their prey.  They are fast and highly agile, able to run and leap in order to attack or escape.

Winner: Shriekers

 

Lifecycle:

Shriekers: Shriekers are the pupa stage of the lifecycle of Graboids and emerge from Graboids generally in groups of 3 to 6.  Shriekers only live on average for 24 hours after which, if they have ingested enough food, they evolve into Assblaster – flying creatures that are similar to Shriekers in many respects.  Given their relatively short lifespan in their Shrieker form, Shriekers do not have the longevity to learn new skills and operate mainly from instinct.  Shriekers are asexual, and by ingesting enough food are able to ‘vomit’ up another Shrieker which will grow to full size within a few hours.  By reproducing in this manner, a small group of newly born Shriekers can become a pack of overwhelming size within a very short period.

Raptors: The Raptors, due to having their DNA spliced with that of amphibians, are able to change their sex if there are too many of the one gender, facilitating being able to breed more efficiently.  Raptors lay eggs and will not only protect their nests fiercely, but even hunt down stolen eggs over vast distances to retrieve them.  Once hatched, baby Raptors follow the species normal life cycle.

Winner: Shriekers

 

Shriekers and Raptors – versus us and each other:

Shriekers & Raptors vs Humans:

In both movie franchises there have been plenty of humans who have been ripped apart by these two predatory species.  But which is best at taking humans out?

Shriekers: Shriekers can run as fast as a human and have enough body weight to pin one down.  They can kill a human with one bite from their powerful jaws, can hunt humans via the mammal’s body heat, and can overwhelm humans by multiplying their numbers exponentially.  They have enough cooperative skills that they can work together to catch their prey such as tunnelling or standing on each other’s shoulders to get humans that are out of reach.  They can shriek in order to alert other Shriekers of a human’s presence, and the genetically modified Shriekers can subdue a human in seconds with the Sonic Scream.  Once a Shrieker has evolved into an Assblaster, they can attack from the air.

Shriekers are able to be tricked very easily by the disguising of body heat.  By keeping solid objects between themselves and the Shrieker, or otherwise lowering their outer body temperature by the use of special clothing, humans can become essentially invisible to Shriekers and avoid them easily. Shriekers have strong bony skulls that can protect them from damage, but the rest of their body is susceptible to gunfire. They can also be killed by bladed weapons being stuck down their throats.

Raptors: Raptors are much bigger and faster than humans so have the speed and strength advantage.  They are intelligent enough to escape pens and traps created by humans, as well as work their way into human strongholds.  They have refined hunting instincts and are able to use a wide variety of tactics to take humans down – everything from using natural cover and distraction techniques, to corralling humans from different directions at once to cut off all escape.  Once caught, humans have no chance of survival in a one-on-one confrontation given the Raptors claws, spurs and teeth.

Raptors are susceptible to gunfire and other weaponry, including shock sticks.  With enough elevation, Raptors have no way to reach a human.

Conclusion: Both creatures are deadly to humans.  Raptors are the more skillful and refined predators.  Shriekers are arguably more dangerous, however are outwitted far more easily.  A draw.

 

Shrieker vs Raptor in a Fight – One on One:

Raptors have it all over Shriekers in terms of their size and speed.  If a Raptor is able to get past the Shriekers protected armoured head, it will easily be able to shred the Shrieker to pieces by grabbing it with its claws, then using its thick foot spurs and sharp teeth to eviscerate it. However, Shriekers are able to easily bite through solid metal with their bony jaws as well as grab their prey/enemies with their prehensile tongues.  With one single solid bite a Shrieker could easily decapitate a Raptor or sever a limb.  So the argument could be made that going head to head a Shrieker would win, but if a Raptor can dodge the Shriekers tongue and that first bite, the Raptor would easily destroy its smaller rival.

However in both franchises Raptors and Shriekers are shown to be genetically tampered with, and in the final movie of the franchise, it is shown that Shriekers now have the ability to emit a Sonic Scream.  As long as the Raptor doesn’t completely take the Shrieker by surprise, which it shouldn’t be able to do even with cover do due to the Shrikers infrared vision, then the Shrieker can easily subdue a Raptor with its disorienting scream, then rip the Raptor to shreds with its huge jaw before the dinosaur realises what’s happening.

Conclusion: A Raptor has more chance of killing a Shrieker in a one-on-one fight, however a genetically modified Shrieker would completely destroy a Raptor.

 

Shriekers vs Raptors in a Fight – Pack vs Pack

Raptors are more intelligent than Shriekers and live far longer, meaning they have the capability to learn how to handle Shriekers from previous stand-offs (assuming any Raptors survive).  It is conceivable that the Raptors could work as a pack, using one of their own as bait to distract the Shriekers whilst the rest of their pack picks off the Shriekers from behind.

However the above technique would probably only result in a few Shriekers getting killed before the rest realise what’s happening.  Once they do the remaining Shriekers should be able to, via their jaws and screams, make short work of the Raptors.  Shriekers also have the strength of numbers.  Raptors have been shown in the movies to hunt in packs of up to 6, whereas with enough food around the Shriekers can not only grow to huge numbers relatively quickly, but also quickly replace any killed members of their pack.  If half the Raptor pack is killed in a battle, they have to wait for their offspring to grow to adulthood to fight, whereas if even one Shrieker lives, it can quickly repopulate its pack within a matter of hours, with Shriekers who live long enough turning into airborne Assblasters to which the Raptors would have no defence.

Conclusion: In Pack vs Pack, the only possible way for the Raptors to win would be to somehow take the Shrieker pack by complete surprise and kill every single one of them as quickly as possible.  In every other scenario the Shriekers win.

 

So who is the overall Winner?

Overall we have to give it to the Shriekers.  Yes, Raptors are bigger, stronger, faster, smarter and have the talons, claws and teeth to back it up.  But Shriekers can reproduce quickly and asexually, use infrared vision to hunt prey, have a bite that can rend metal and the genetically modified ones can use a Sonic Scream to subdue most anything or anyone.  If you combine those factors with their  armoured heads and prehensile tongues then the Raptors, essentially big clever lizards, don’t stand a chance.  In this competition of the hunters, Jurassic loses out to Pre-Cambrian.

 

Do you think the above comparisons between these fictitious creatures are accurate?   And would you be interested in a potential T-Rex vs Graboid comparison?  If so pop it in the comments section below!